The Explorers tree outside Katoomba has been the subject of debate for generations.
In 1813 the three men pictured above set out to cross the Blue Mountains of New South Wales, keeping to the ridges, rather than the deep, forested valleys. Accompanied by five servants, they were the first European settlers to succeed.
I think we would all agree that the tree (Eucalyptus oreades ) is a sad sight. But to be honest, t’was (almost) ever thus. By the 1880s it was dead, and posing a danger to visitors and passers by. It was said that the explorers had carved their initials on the trunk, but if true they had long vanished.
In 1904 the top was chopped off and taken to the newly built Hydro Majestic Hotel. The plan was for it to be fashioned into a relic for guests to admire. Unfortunately it was destroyed during a bush fire, in 1922.
Did Blaxland, Wentworth and Lawson, really carve their initials on the trunk in 1813? It seems unlikely. There is no documented evidence, and the first mention of it did not appear until the 1860s. Some people have suggested it was all a hoax, to lure visitors up the mountains in those early days.
Of course the tree stump was soon a target for people wanting to leave their own mark;
We passed in the first mile a much over-rated and doubtful relic – “Wentworth’s Tree”. I have seen a good many better trees. Why the tree next to it is better. The thing isn’t a tree at all; it is an old dead stump, a fraud, not worth the trouble of putting a railing around. There are said still to remain upon it the initials of the three explorers. Three? Wentworth must have had a big party. John Smith, Annie Smith (ladies, too), Henry Jones, William Mulqueeney – and dozens of others. At all events, Wentworth, though he may have been a good explorer, had no knowledge of timber.
Graffiti remained a problem down the years. In 1939 a local newspaper reported; It is a matter for regret that ‘visitors’ have found means of hacking their initials on the coping of this monument. Left alone in Westminster Abbey, such fiends would not hesitate about scratching their worthless names on the tomb of the Unknown Warrior.
At one point it was suggested that the stump should be protected under a glass dome. The following exchange at a council meeting was reported in The Blue Mountains Echo in 1926;
The Mayor – The glass case would not last a week up there!
Alderman Lamont commented that the subject was no joking matter. He said he had been told that a young tree could be grafted to the stump. This created more levity with people calling out, ‘ It’s Dead!‘
Alderman Collins – And half eaten by white ants.
The Mayor – It has been suggested that it should be cut down and removed to the Town Hall.
Alderman Collins – But it’s loaded with white ants.
Alderman Hendry – Why not remove it to the Town Hall and substitute a model at the present site?
Alderman Collins – I move that we advise the Town Planning Association of the condition of the tree and suggest that it should erect a monument to mark the spot.
The resolution was adopted but nothing came of it. By the way, it wasn’t the first time a glass case had been suggested;
The sacred relic, known as the Explorers’ Tree on the Bathurst-road near Katoomba, N.S.W., has been photographed for pictorial illustration no fewer than a hundred and sixty seven thousand times, and still some of the wood remains. The stump should be preserved in a glass case to show the durability of our hardwood. (Truth Newspaper, June 12 1913)
At some point the rotted core was filled with concrete and steel bands were placed to hold the increasingly flimsy shell together. A car crashed into the surrounding wall of the stump in 2012 and since then it has become a bit of an eyesore.
In the end it doesn’t really matter whether the explorers carved their initials on the tree or not. It still stands as a memorial to their great achievement. Perhaps what’s left needs to be incorporated within another monument. I understand the Blue Mountains Council applied for and received a $100,000 grant from the State Government to do something, so we can only hope.
There is another complication in all this. If there is to be a replacement monument, should it remain at the Katoomba site, or be placed where the 1813 expedition ended? Oddly enough there were claims of another marked tree at Mount Blaxland, and photos as well.
It should be noted that Mt. Blaxland is on private property. Regardless of any decision, I do love the concluding lines in a poem written by Roderick Quinn, in 1920;
UPDATE – The Blue Mountains Council responded to this story. The government grant was awarded in August 2018. Council are still formulating plans for an upgrade of the whole site.